The Millionaire, His Mistress, His Will & the ex-Governor
A current Georgia case vividly illustrates the legal, emotional and moral complexity often involved in estates litigation. According to the reports, Harvey Strother died at age 78, having succumbed to progressively severe alcoholism brought on by the tragic death of his daughter at age 23. Strother had built up a formidable nest of car dealerships around Georgia, dying with a net worth of about US$37 million. And a mistress 30 years his junior.
At issue are 3 amendments to Strother's 1988 will in favour of his mistress. The will had left the bulk of his estate to his wife, their children and grandchildren. But one amendment gave his mistress a $7,900 monthly allowance, a second gave her health insurance and an island condo in Florida. The third - signed about a month before Strother's death - gave her a Cape Cod cottage, a Florida boat slip and a Florida condo to her son. By that time Strother was drinking 1.5 gallons of wine a day (about 6.8 liters, or 9 bottles of wine).
At trial, the jury upheld the first two amendments, worth about $4.5 million to the mistress. However, the third one was invalid. Strother, was allegedly drinking even before he signed it and brought to the lawyer's office by his mistress, and his signature was illegible.
The family is appealing the two amendments that were upheld, one on the basis that the witnesses were not even present (the mistress is appealing the third amendment struck out by the jury). Interestingly, the family is represented by Georgia's ex-Governor Roy Barnes, who points out that the requirement for two witnesses "is an elementary part of the law that has been there since the time of Edward II." FYI, King Edward II, 1284 - 1327: yes, we deal with old law in estates litigation.
Have a great day,
Chris Graham
