Ontario's Unforgiving Formal Execution Requirements for Wills
The formal requirements for execution of a will, or any testamentary instrument in Ontario, are governed by Part I of the Succession Law Reform Act ("SLRA"). The definition of "will" in s. 1 of the SLRA includes a testament, codicil, will, or other testamentary disposition. The most critical form requirements are that the will must be in writing, signed by the testator and two witnesses. Other requirements exist, of course.
Many jurisdictions contain dispensation clauses relaxing the formal compliance requirements, if the court is satisfied that a document or any writing on a document embodies the testamentary intentions of a deceased. For example, s. 23 of Manitoba's Wills Act or California's Probate Section 6110-6113. Not so with Ontario, except for holograph wills and for members of the Canadian Forces on active service. While there is wiggle room in terms of the interpretation of the execution requirements, for instance what constitutes "in writing" or "signed by the testator", if the formal requirements are not met and no specific exemption applies, there is no saving provision based on testator's intention, and therefore no testamentary instrument.
This can have harsh consequences, by invalidating otherwise perfectly good wills on narrow technical grounds. On the other hand, the SLRA provides time-tested, black-letter legal clarity. Time tested, because the formal requirements descend from the Wills Act, 1837.
Have a great weekend,
Chris Graham
Christopher M.B. Graham - Click here for more information on Chris Graham.
